Who you gonna call? What’s the difference between a ghostwriter and an editor? - The Ghost Writing Blog
There are many euphemisms for what I do. I’ve been credited as a co-author, writer, editor and (my personal favourite) ‘the lady who typed my memoirs’. Often I am not acknowledged at all. I am happy either way. My job is to write books for other people and stay in the background.
Out of all the acknowledgements I receive, the most common is ‘editor’. At the risk of sounding pedantic, or doing myself out of future nods for my contribution, strictly speaking, a ghostwriter is not really an editor at all. In traditional publishing, ghost writing and editing are very different disciplines.
In the simplest (perhaps somewhat glib) terms, ghost writers write a book for someone else, while an editor ‘fixes’ someone else’s writing. But let me explain in more detail.
A ghostwriter will write a book based on the named author’s memories, ideas or previous work, or a combination of all three, in exchange for a fee. Sometimes the ghost will start from scratch, interviewing the author over a series of sessions, while at other times the author may already have a part-written manuscript they need help with. The ghost, who is usually an experienced writer with knowledge of the publishing industry, will take the sometimes jumbled thoughts of the author, make sense of it all and then ensure the resulting book is a well-structured, compelling read. As noted above, there is no obligation to give credit to the ghostwriter, but some authors choose to do so.
Authors use ghostwriters for a number of reasons. They may not actually enjoy writing, or perhaps don’t feel they write well, or, very commonly because they simply don’t have the time to pen an entire book. Hiring a ghost is the easiest way to ensure a book is finished in the least amount of time and in the optimum condition to be published.
Which brings me neatly to the next stage in the process: editing.
When I complete the majority of manuscripts, there will be just two people on the planet who will have read what I have written: the author and me. That is not enough to green light the text for immediate publishing. Books need to be edited.
When a book is complete and both author and ghostwriter are satisfied, it is sent to an editor. The editor will proofread the book, checking it for spelling, punctuation and grammar errors. Importantly, they will provide a completely new perspective, which picks up any inconsistencies in the story, or incomplete threads. It doesn’t matter how good your ghost is, these things do occasionally get missed.
An editor will invariably take a harsh stance on sections that lack clarity, or are simply redundant. Often, after labouring over a book for six months, a ghost or editor might not be as willing to admit that some parts of the book were not as strong as they hoped. Trust me, an editor won’t be as reticent. Editors are also sticklers for citations too: if external material is quoted they will expect full references.
What an editor won’t do is re-write the content, or re-arrange chapters. If they feel revisions are needed, they will return the book to the author/ghostwriter with suggestions for alternative wording, or chapter layouts. It is up to the writing team to fix any rough spots. When the partnership between the editor and writers works well, the end result is the five star bestseller version of the original.
While ghostwriting and editing are two very different disciplines, there are some similarities. Both parties have a gift for getting to the true heart of a story and for the optimum way to present it to the world. They’ll also have a firm grasp of language and a talent for understanding and projecting the named author’s voice. Where they differ substantially is editors are more like passive observers, guiding an author with a mainly hands-off approach. Meanwhile ghosts build a relationship with an author, actively guiding the direction of the book to transform the author’s thoughts into a highly sellable book.
- How to find a ghostwriter for an autobiography
- The pros and cons of hiring a ghostwriter
- Why do entrepreneurs hire ghostwriters?
- Selling your book to a publisher – how to write a book proposal
- How can I write a book about my life?
- Thirteen years as a ghostwriter – what have I learned?
- Make money from writing: simple ways to become a ghostwriter
- How common are ghostwriters?
- Ghostwriting – expectations versus reality
- Planning your book part 2. How long should a chapter be?
- How to plan a book – paper and scissors required
- Ghostwriting contracts and agreements: how to protect yourself if a collaboration goes wrong
- Do you need a ghostwriter for your book? Publishers seem to think so.
- How to find a ghostwriter
- Submitting a manuscript to a publisher or agent – why does the process take so long?
- Print vs ebook: Which format is right for you?
- Making your true story readable – what is narrative non fiction writing?
- How and where to research when writing a non fiction book
- I’m writing a biography. What tense should I use in my book?
- How to start your novel
- What should my business book be about? Business book ideas.
- How to distribute your self published book
- Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, right? Wrong. How to write a book without plagiarising
- Can you write a book with the same title as another?
- What’s in a name? Can you write a book anonymously?
- How to get feedback on your book
- How to work with a ghostwriter: what does the author do?
- How to work with a ghostwriter – the interview process
- Ghostwriter versus co-writer
- Can self published books be successful?
- Is ghostwriting ethical?
- How does a ghostwriter keep the voice?
- Perfect pictures: Sourcing photographs for your book
- Why write a business book? Because it is the best way to get noticed. Ever.
- What to do with a book before submitting to a publisher: how to prepare a manuscript for publication
- Rejection could be viewed as a redirection. But why was my manuscript rejected?
- The piece of string question: how many pages should my manuscript be?
- Urgently seeking authors: how to get ghostwriting clients.
- Who you gonna call? What’s the difference between a ghostwriter and an editor?
- Transparent pricing: How much does a ghostwriter charge?
- All you need to know about how to write a bestselling business book
- I can write perfectly well myself: so why do authors use a ghost writer?
- If a ghostwriter can’t say what they’ve written, how do they provide writing samples?
- Your name on the cover – but does a ghost get rights to a book?
- How do you know if a book is ghostwritten?
- Should I Self-Publish My Novel?
- How To Use Facebook Advertising To Sell A Book
- Should You Use Slang In A Novel?
- How To Overcome Writer’s Block
- How To Market & Sell Your Book
- How To Come Up With A Title For Your Novel
- 5 Things You Should Know When Working With A Ghostwriter
- Lazy words and stuff
- Finally ‘Cool’